Replay Andersonville Menu (Update 2025)
Replay Andersonville is a unique establishment that blends arcade entertainment with a sports bar atmosphere and American cuisine. Located at 5358 N Clark St in Chicago, IL, this restaurant offers a wide range of amenities including delivery, takeout, reservations, and outdoor seating. The menu boasts a variety of shareable dishes like Fried Dill Pickles, Buffalo Chicken Egg Rolls, and Wisconsin Cheese Curds. The wraps and salads selection features options like the Apple and Cranberry Salad, Chicken Pesto Wrap, and Buffalo Chicken Salad. Taco and quesadilla enthusiasts can indulge in dishes such as Birria Beef Quesatacos and Chicken Quesadilla. Customers rave about the friendly service, retro games, and evolving menu at Replay Andersonville, making it a must-visit spot for casual dining and entertainment.
Shareables
Fried Dill Pickles
Panko breaded fried pickle chips, chipotle buttermilk ranch dressing.
Replay Nachos
Pepper jack cheese, guacamole, roasted tomato salsa, pico de gallo, pickled peppers and sour cream. Substitute tater tots for tortilla chips at no charge, add protein for an additional charge.
Buffalo Chicken Egg Rolls
3 crispy egg rolls filled with smoked chicken, blue cheese and Buffalo sauce. Served with blue cheese or buttermilk ranch.
Crispy Cauliflower
Deep fried, rice-flour coated cauliflower, spicy curry, and pickle salad.
Wisconsin Cheese Curds
Battered, fried and garnished with pickled red onion, and served with ranch dipping sauce.
Replay Chicken Wings
8 pieces. Tossed in Buffalo, BBQ, or our signature hot honey mustard sauce. Served with celery sticks and your choice of buttermilk ranch dressing or blue cheese dressing.
Pan Seared Brussels Sprouts
Sofrito aioli, balsamic reduction, Parmesan cheese.
Toasted Chickpea Hummus
Roasted poblano, chickpea and caper chutney with grilled pita bread, fresh jicama and celery.
Curried Deviled Eggs
Chipotle Spinach, Kale and Feta Cheese Empanadas
Homemade.
Beef and Chihuahua Cheese Empanadas
Homemade.
Crispy Pork Belly
Spicy Asian glaze, topped with pineapple and Poblano relish.
Heirloom Tomato Gazpacho
Summer blend garnished with sweet watermelon, mint herb oil and heirloom cherry tomatoes.
BBQ Brisket Sliders
Slow cooked and smoked. Tossed in bourbon BBQ sauce and topped with coleslaw.
Andersonville Swedish Meatballs
Traditional Swedish style pork and beef meatballs.
Today's Seasonal Soup
Please contact restaurant for today's selection.
Italian Meatballs
Pork and beef meatballs served with spicy marinara sauce, topped with Parmesan cheese.
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Served with lightly fried pita chips.
Roasted Red Pepper Hummus
Served with celery and grilled pita bread
Duck Empanadas
Duck, guajillo chili, chihuahua cheese
Apple and Cranberry Salad
Fresh spring mix, honey crisp apple, dried cranberries, blue cheese crumbles and candied walnuts tossed in honey-yuzu vinaigrette.
Chicken Pesto Wrap
Grilled chicken breast, baby spinach, fresh Parmesan cheese, homemade pesto. Served with choice of side.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken breast tossed in Buffalo sauce with your choice of ranch or blue cheese dressing, lettuce and tomato
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken breast tossed in Buffalo sauce with your choice of ranch or blue cheese dressing, lettuce and tomato. Served with choice of side.
Replay Cobb Salad
Vegetarian cobb with romaine, green onions, avocado, tomato, hard-boiled egg, bleu cheese, ranch dressing.
Replay Cobb Wrap
Vegetarian cobb with romaine, green onions, avocado, tomato, hard-boiled egg, bleu cheese, ranch dressing. Served with choice of side.
Kohlrabi and Fennel Appetizer Salad
Ginger maple dressing with mixed greens, Honeycrisp apple and candied walnuts.
Kohlrabi and Fennel Entree Salad
Ginger maple dressing with mixed greens, Honeycrisp apple and candied walnuts.
Lime-Grilled Shrimp Salad
Romaine, arugula, avocado, cilantro, pickled peppers, jicama, queso fresco, tortilla chips and citrus vinaigrette.
Beet Salad
Spring mix, baby arugula, roasted beets, green beans, shiitake mushrooms, tomato, toasted almonds and shaved avalon cheese tossed with shallot vinegar.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, brioche croutons, homemade Caesar dressing.
Caesar Wrap
Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, brioche croutons, homemade Caesar dressing. Served with choice of side.
Santa Fe Salad
Romaine lettuce, fresh corn, black beans, queso fresco, tortilla strips and tomato with a spicy peanut cilantro vinaigrette.
Small Mixed Green Salad
Cherry tomato, cucumber, mixed greens and balsamic vinaigrette.
Bourbon BBQ Ranch Chicken Salad
Avocado, tomato, grilled corn, black beans, cucumber and romaine lettuce tossed with bourbon BBQ ranch dressing and topped with crispy onion strings.
Fennel and Daikon Radish Salad
Baby arugula, shaved fennel, daikon radish, candied pecans, tomatoes, red onions and pomegranate seeds tossed with pomegranate dressing.
Shrimp Salad
Romaine, arugula, avocado, cilantro, pickled peppers, jicama, queso fresco, tortilla chips, tossed in a citrus vinaigrette and topped with grilled shrimp.
Bok Choy Salad
Bok Choy leaves, Brussels Sprouts, Arugula, Candied Pistachios, Lemon Vinaigrette
Replay Farmer's Salad
Farm Greens, Watermelon, Grapes, Tomatoes, Pepitas, Almonds, Dried Goji Berries, Feta Cheese, Sherry Vinaigrette, Pomegranate Gastrique
Santa Fe Wrap
Romaine lettuce, fresh corn, black beans, queso fresco, tortilla strips and tomato with a spicy peanut cilantro vinaigrette. Served with choice of side.
Wraps and Salads
Tacos and Quesadillas
Birria Beef Quesatacos
Slow-cooked savory Mexican-style beef tacos with Chihuahua cheese crust, pickled red onions, and cilantro with a side of consume and lime.
Birria Beef Quesadilla
Slow-cooked savory Mexican-style beef with Chihuahua cheese and salsa verde.
Chicken Quesadilla
Grilled chicken, poblano peppers, and pepper jack cheese. Served with roasted salsa and sour cream.
Build-A-Burger
8 oz. USDA ground chuck burger patty topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, dill pickles and served on a fresh buttery bun.
Jalapeno Bacon Burger
8 oz. USDA ground chuck burger patty, queso fresco, bacon, arugula, and our house-made pickled jalapeno and red onion relish on a pretzel bun.
NEW Fig and Brie Burger
8oz USDA ground chuck burger patty, Brie cheese, caramelized onions, arugula and fig jam on a buttery bun
Double Smashed Burger
2 quarter pound hamburger patties, applewood smoked bacon, American cheese, caramelized onions, tomato, arugula, and fried dill pickles on a buttery bun.
Bourbon Burger
8 oz. USDA ground chuck burger patty, melted bleu cheese, and bourbon BBQ sauce on a pretzel bun with Lettuce, tomato, dill pickles, and onion.
Hawaiian Burger
8oz USDA ground chuck burger patty, applewood smoked ham, provolone cheese, caramelized onions and our house made grilled pineapple relish on a pretzel bun
Impossible Burger Deluxe
Impossible burger, smoked tomato aioli, avocado and provolone cheese, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion and dill pickle on a buttery bun.
Burgers
Sandwiches
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Grilled marinated chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, onion, dill pickles, fresh buttery bun.
Replay Cubano Sandwich
Braised pork shoulder, smoked ham, applewood bacon, Monterey Jack cheese, dill pickles, mustard aioli and pickled peppers, served on griddled telera bread.
Replay Reuben Sandwich
House-braised corned beef, Swiss cheese, caraway sauerkraut, Russian dressing on grilled rye bread.
Steak Sandwich
USDA choice flat iron steak, baby arugula, grilled onion, homemade pesto, garlic aioli on a French baguette.
Reply BLT Sandwich
Our classic BLT bacon, lettuce, and tomato on white toast. Add extras for an additional charge.
Roasted Mushroom Sandwich
Roasted hen of the woods and oyster mushrooms, pickled onions, mixed lettuce greens, truffle aioli with shallots and garlic on French bread
Replay Banh Mi Sandwich
Grilled shrimp, smoked meatloaf, crunchy vegetable slaw, lime dressing basil and mint
Fried Chicken Sandwhich
Fried chicken breast served with chipotle ranch, arugula, tomato, and dill pickles on a brioche bun.
New York Strip Steak
Pan seared New York steak. Served with mashed potatoes and green beans in a Madeira wine sauce.
Pappardelle Bolognese
Homemade pasta with pork ragout, rosemary and pickled grapes.
Roasted Chicken Breast
Fruit brined with lemon pan sauce, roasted red potatoes and sauteed green beans.
Smoked Chicken Thighs
Boneless chicken thighs, Hen of the Woods Mushrooms, Bok Choy, Mustard Gremolata, Crispy Potatoes
Curried Baby Back Ribs
Baby Back Ribs, Vindaloo Curry, Smoked Yogurt Sauce, Cilantro, Radish, Crispy Potatoes
Wild Boar Sausage
Pickled fennel-onion salad, whole grain mustard, Crispy Potatoes
Grilled Pork Steak "Secreto"
Charred Asparagus, Shallots, Chilies, Mild Oyster Sauce, Crispy Potatoes
Replay Meatloaf
Hickory smoked, homemade mashed potatoes and bourbon gravy.
Baked Mac and Cheese
Andersonville's best mac and cheese! (Available after 5pm)Cavatappi noodles with Cheddar, Velveeta, and smoked Applewood bacon, baked au gratin with panko crumbles.
Pan Fried Chicken Dinner
Pan fried Chicken breast with mashed potatoes, bourbon gravy & fresh green beans
Buffalo Shrimp & Cheddar Cheese Grits
Grilled shrimp, buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese grits
Turkey Pot Pie
House brined turkey with carrots, peas, celery and potatoes topped with puffed pastry
Steak and Potatoes
USDA Choice Flat Iron steak with madeira sauce and oyster mushrooms, served with roasted red potatoes
Chicken Milanese
Sauted breaded chicken breast, fettuccine, sun-dried tomato pesto sauce, mushrooms, parmesan
Pasta Primavera
3 color fettucine, shallots, garlic, grape tomatoes, spinach, pesto, and parmesan
Andouille Mac & Cheese
Our house made cheese sauce, bread crumbs, and sliced andouille sausage
Chicken Tender Dinner
Served with your choice of fries or mixed green salad(with cucumber tomatoes and balsamic dressing). Choose a sauce: ranch, BBQ, Buffalo sauce, hot honey mustard, bourbon BBQ, or garlic aioli.
Comfort Food
Sides
Hand-Cut French Fries
Tater Tots
Fresh Fruit Salad
Homemade Mashed Potatoes with Bourbon Gravy
Brussel Sprouts - side
Sweet Potato Fries
Side Mixed Green Salad
Mixed green salad with tomatoes and cucumber. Comes with side of balsamic dressing
Mashed Potatoes
Homemade garlic mashed potatoes with bourbon gravy
Extra Sauce
Side of Guacamole
Side of Tortilla Chips
Side of Avocado
Chips and Salsa
Crunchy tortilla chips with side of house roasted tomato salsa
Seasonal Pumpkin Bread Pudding
House-made pumpkin bread pudding made with Challah bread, topped with candied walnuts, bourbon caramel, and vanilla ice cream.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet
30 minutes bake time. Chocolate chip cookie baked in cast iron skillet, topped with vanilla ice cream and bourbon caramel.
Brownie Sundae
Warm brownie with Ghirardelli chocolate chips, served with chocolate sauce, vanilla ice cream and whipped cream
Vanilla Ice Cream
3 scoops of vanilla ince cream
House-Made Desserts
Flatbreads
Mozzarella & Basil Flatbread
Mozzarella & Parmesan cheese, basil pesto, arugula, and house-made marinara sauce
Verde Chicken Flatbread
Tomatillo salsa, fresh corn, grilled chicken, cilantro, pepper jack and chihuahua cheese.
Italian Flatbread
Artichokes, goat cheese, cherry tomatoes, pesto and a balsamic reduction.
Sausage & Pesto Flatbread
Homemade Wild Boar Sausage, Pesto, Onions, Mozzarella, Tomatoes, Smoked Ricotta
Birria Tacos
3 Birria beef tacos with Chihuahua cheese crust, pickled red onions, served with roastedtomato salsa.
Bok Choy Wrap
Bok choy leaves, Brussels sprouts, arugula, candied pistachios, lemon vinaigrette
Single-Decker Roast Turkey Club
Bacon, romaine lettuce, sliced tomato, mayo, Muenster cheese and multigrain toast. Served with choice of side.
Ratatouille Wrap
Grilled zucchini, squash, portobello, baby spinach, feta cheese, hummus and roasted pepper coulis in a whole wheat tortilla. Served with choice of side.
Smoked Chicken Sandwich
Smoked chicken thigh, baby arugula, pickled red onion, roasted tomato and pesto aioli on an onion roll. Served with choice of side.
BBQ Brisket Sandwich
Slow cooked and smoked brisket with homemade BBQ sauce. Topped with coleslaw and served on an onion roll with choice of side.
Chipotle Lime Shrimp Replay Tacos
3 Milagro corn tortilla tacos with sauteed chipotle lime shrimp, jicama slaw, pickled fresnos and tomatillo salsa. Served with watermelon and arugula salad.
Pork and Beef Burger
Sage and garlic ground pork and beef, crispy onions, over-medium egg, provolone cheese, Dijonaise and sesame seed bun. Includes choice of side.
Pulled Pork Replay Tacos
Pulled pork with Guajillo salsa, and pickled red onions. Served with Mexican rice.
Corned Beef & Swiss
House-braised corned beef, caramelized onions, horseradish mustard, on a baguette.
Crispy Beef Sandwich
Crispy braised beef belly, horseradish gochujang sauce, lettuce, Monterey Jack cheese, pickle
Crispy Beef & Burger
Crispy beef belly, beef burger patty, horseradish gochujang, Monterey Jackcheese, lettuce, pickle, pretzel bun
Wraps & Handhelds
Specials & Seasonal Offerings
Roll of Toilet Paper
1 roll of 2 PLY toilet paper!!
Smoked Chicken Thighs Dinner for Two
Boneless smoked Chicken Thighs Hen of the wood mushrooms, bok choy, mustard gremolata, crispy potatoes.Choice of Caeser or Mixed Green Dinner Salad
Meatloaf Dinner (feeds 4)
Hickory smoked meatloaf, homemade mashed potatoes, bourbon gravy.Choice of dinner salad for 4 people
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Slow-cooked pulled pork, with tangy BBQ sauce, coleslaw, and your choice of side!
Family Pulled Pork Meal
Slow-cooked pulled pork, 4 homemade biscuits, Coleslaw, and Fries or Tater Tots(feeds 4)
Easter Ham Dinner
Sliced Ham, Roasted Potatoes, Asparagus
Easter Lamb Dinner
Rack of lamb, chimichurri sauce, roasted potatoes
Beef Tip Special
10oz beef tip with garlic mash potatoes, sauted spinach and garlic demi glace
Thanksgiving Dinner
Traditional Thanksgiving Dinner - options for salad, main course and dessert. Served with Butternut Squash Soup
Thanksgiving Dinner for Two
A traditional Thanksgiving dinner for two people!